Reading by Lightning by Joan Thomas

Reading by Lightning by Joan Thomas

Goose Lane Editions, Fredericton, New Brunswick, 2008

I own this one.  It won the Commonwealth Writer’s Prize in 2009 and the Amazon First Novel Award.

I cannot remember where I first learned of this book.  It might have been on the CBC website or through Amazon CA.  All I know is I waited for months to see if the library would buy a copy and then just couldn’t wait any longer.

Reading by Lightning is the story of Lily Piper, a young girl growing up in a farming community in Saskatchewan.  Her father traveled to Canada from England, following the charismatic preacher Isaac Barr, and his followers wait for a moment of rapture when they will rise up to heaven.  Lily is restless and rebellious, not as compliant as her Mother would like.  She has an irrepressible urge to break free.

At sixteen she is sent to England to care for her Grandmother.  There she meets her father’s family, revels in her freedom and falls in love, only to be called back to Canada by her family.

In Lily, we find a young girl full of deep thoughts and strong feeling.  Her struggle to break out and discover herself is one all adolescents endure and Thomas has written of it with beauty and grace.  This is another one of those books I find difficult to describe.  It is sprawling, covering decades, and yet so delicate and precise it is a joy to read.

And of course, no one talked back then, except about things that happened a long time ago.  When I try to tell about our life I am struck by how thin and poor my words are.  The dog’s dish, with its chipped enamel rim, battered by being driven over when I left it out in the yard.  The chair with the broken back.  The clock, our clock, with the hand that struggled to cross over the top of the hour.  The goat.  Things have just one words for them –dish, chair, clock, goat.  The biggest crime you could commit against your neighbor was aspiring to anything fancier, especially words.  The Parrot’s goat might have been made to show how poor and mean words are.  From page 79

..Once I boarded the SS Franconia it was different: there we were all held in a little society in which it seemed I had to account for myself.  Sometimes I thought the other passengers were piqued by my naiveté, and during the cool, sunny days when everyone strolled on deck I leaned against the railing and looked out to the horizon as though this were my habitual attitude, gazing across endless fields of rippling wheat.  That’s how I made my way across the ocean,playing the role of the unspoiled, forthright farm girl.   One night in the dining room a man in a shabby brown suit talked about the drought on the prairies. It’s the sign of the end times, I said boldly.  It’s in the Book of Revelations.  There’s a drought on the prairies every thirty years, said the man.  It’s a natural cycle.  He didn’t bother even to glance at me again.  And then my longing for England was fierce, for England, where I would be someone else, although I didn’t know then who that would be.  From page 136.

The story moves between first person and third person points of view but I did not find this a distraction.  Thomas is a fine writer and I will be happy if she publishes another novel.


Filed under CanadianBookChallenge3, Historical Fiction, New Authors 2010

11 responses to “Reading by Lightning by Joan Thomas

  1. This looks so great! I’d never even heard of it before, but I need to read more Canadian authors anyway, and I love the synopsis and the excerpts you’ve posted. I always like it when protagonists go off to live with a completely different group of people to what they’re used to.

  2. I’d like to read this one too — your review has made it sound the most appealing of any I’ve read so far. Thomas has written another book, it just came out, called Curiosity

  3. I really enjoyed this one, too. It was one of the first ones I read for the WWII challenge last year.


  4. Mir

    She has published a new novel! Just out in Canada. It’s called Curiosity and looks fabulous. I can’t wait to read it.

  5. How did I miss this book! I must see if I can get a copy…

  6. Me again. I was just looking at the library, and it looks like she has a new book out in case you are interested. It looks good, but I will start with this one.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s